The stocky, deep-lined, grey-thatched man at the next table pops the word out like a bullet from a silenced revolver. Like a curse, an oath, a little votive offering. Like a verbal full stop. He spits it quietly, accompanied by a light tap of his glass on the scratched and spartan tabletop. His companions don’t seem to hear him, or pay him no notice if they do. They’re busily masticating chorizo, salt cod omelette, T-bone. But I hear him and, novice though I am, I know the score. He’s the bloke looking after the round. It’s a summons, a call to arms.
We weave through the bustling, warm, clackety tumult of the dining room and all at once the ceiling billows, caverns, vaults church-like upwards. The smells shift from heat and fat and meat and oil to coolness and dampness and juice and acid. Two ranked lines of barrels – no, too small a word – vessels; great arks of chestnut flank the nave, thinned out pockets of people mill around the sticky, booze-glistened stone floor and a longer line stretches towards one of the vast casks where a slender, glittering beam of cider bursts forth from its face, pattering and splashing into wide, impossibly thin proffered glasses.
Welcome to the Basque country. Welcome, specifically, to Hernani. We’re a twenty-minute bus ride from San Sebastián and we’re here in the last gasps of winter for txotx. There are dozens of cideries – Sagardotegias – across the town and its neighbour Astigarraga, and from the end of January to the start of April, almost every one of them will be serving a txotx dinner almost every evening to – depending on the cidery’s size – up to hundreds of people. By the time the season closes, providing it isn’t cut short by a pandemic, as it was this year, something in the region of 800,000 people will have attended. And every single one of them is drinking cider.
Txotx means “toothpick”. There’s a tiny hole drilled into the face of each barrel, bunged by a splinter of wood. Pop the splinter and that slender shaft of cider drills out, fired by the pressure behind it. Catch it in your glass, from a distance, and you’ll have a light, temporary carbonation. It doesn’t last long, so you catch just an inch or so at a time and gulp it down on the spot, small sips be-damned.
The “txotx” season began as just a way for cideries to show the new season’s cider to merchants, private customers and the local gastronomic societies common to San Sebastián. Taste the barrels, pick your favourite. Actually, since you’re coming, bring some grub, would you? We’ve got the meat, so if you do the chorizo, he’ll do an omelette and we’ll figure out the cheese when we get there. As the years ticked along a txotx menu formed and consolidated: chorizo in cider … salt cod omelette … cod loin with peppers … t-bone steaks … cheeses with quince jelly. It’s what you’ll be served wherever you go, and believe me, you won’t want anything else. San Seb is one of the world’s food capitals, and the food in the txotx houses was as good as we ate all week. Thirty euros, give or take, gets you all of the above, and as many goes at the barrels as you can stand. It’s a thief’s bargain.
The geophysicist and I have come to Zelaia. I did some digging before our visit, as you’d expect, and Zelaia was on my shortlist anyway. But Little Pomona’s Susanna Forbes told me it was the not-to-be-missed cidery, and that sold it. We arrive half an hour before kickoff to be shown around by Maialen, one of the sisters who runs the cidery. Zelaia’s on the larger end of the medium-sized houses in the Basque country, making somewhere in the region of 400,000 litres a year. Every drop of it is dry, every drop is full-juice, natural. Apples, apples, more apples and nothing but. The production room is an ordered medley of pristine stainless steel. Two big, pneumatic presses loom large. “Like the wine trade”, I comment. Yes, that’s where they came from. Zelaia’s one of the few cideries that uses them. Gentler on apple pomace, better for purer, cleaner flavours. Another machine is less familiar; it looks like the slotted carcass of an industrial tumble drier. It turns out to be for removing leaves and detritus from the apples before milling. Wine-inspired again.
Cideries out here don’t tend to have long lines of products, and Zelaia’s no exception – they make only three, in line with the relatively recent PDO changes. Gorenak – cider made with apples harvested both inside and outside the Basque Country. Euskal Sagardoa – only Basque apples qualify. And Euskal Sagardoa Premium. The Gold top. Basque apples only, and independently adjudged to be of significantly superior quality. That paucity of different lines makes blending a fine art indeed – especially when the variation across the giant casks is considered. We try one that Maialen describes as “tannic for us … nothing compared to England or France”. It’s full, ripe, peachy. But she’s right; those tannins would barely register on the West Country or Cotentin Richter scale.
Basque cider – indeed Spanish cider in general – isn’t about the tannin. There might be a trace, and they do grow a handful of bittersweet apples, but this is sharps country. Spanish cider’s all about the kind of acidity that can hiss and skewer through oil and fat; a cutting edge set alight by starbursts of citrus and tropical fruits. There’s a caveat with that though: those big barrels let a lot of oxygen in … and there’s a lot of acetic acid around. So much so that Spanish ciders often struggle in international competitions judged by international palates. Proper pouring, from a distance, slightly reduces the perception of the acetic, but once bottles are in the hands of consumers, that’s difficult to police. Maialen’s of the opinion that acetic levels need to be controlled more in any case – by fermenting and cellaring hers in cooler conditions she’s reduced Zelaia’s to an imperceptible level. A lead that I feel some other cideries would be well advised to follow.
We pop a few more barrels before Maialen excuses herself – she’s on chef duty, with a hundred-odd customers to cook for. And then it’s off to the dining room with us too, standing up, elbows on tables, for course after course of rich, indulgent, mesmerising brilliance, punctured by the frequent mutters of “txotx” from the next table, and lashings of pristine, dew-fresh cider under the cellarmaster’s eye. It’s fast, it’s dynamic, it’s riotous. It is food and drink – it’s dinner – but it is also performance; theatre and festival. You stuff down a course, wipe it up with the bottomless bread, then join a line to catch the cider with the inside edge of your glass and dash back to the table to find a new course has arrived. It’s not just about the cider, or the ritual, or the food, but the interweaving of all three. Without any one element the whole thing would be diminished; none is more or less important than any other. Finally, stomachs creaking, spirits aglow, we head out into the lukewarm, breathy darkness of a late Basque evening and catch the last bus home.
Two days later we’re standing in another Sagardotegia. A bigger one, Zapiain, the biggest of the lot. It’s mid afternoon, we’re the only people here, and the huge, empty cidery seems to echo with the absent ghosts and roar of txotx because of it. Zapiain’s twice the size of Zelaia, but again everything is natural; everything is made from whole juice. There may be vast stainless steel tanks, but the presses are still pneumatic, still gentle; sensitive to the apple, still all about the quality. And in another hall those huge, hulking rows of massive chestnut casks are still stoppered by slender, traditional toothpicks.
Cider has been made here by the Zapiain family for nearly four hundred and fifty years – quite possibly a chunk longer. But what sets out their range from other producers is the diversity of their liquid portfolio. I’m put in mind of Burrow Hill – like them, Zapiain have a still, an alembic in the cognac style, and they’ve been distilling since the eighties. They don’t have quite the same age range of brandies as Burrow Hill; your options are simply with or without oak, but there’s a pommeau and an ice cider as well and tasty they all are too. At the local cider museum our guide says that Zapiain leads the region when it comes to innovation, and I don’t dispute it. But that doesn’t mean they’ve turned their back on the classics; their Gorenak, Euskal Sagardoa and Euskal Sagardoa Premium are popularly acknowledged as some of the best drinking around, all leaning down the more tropical end of the Basque spectrum, reflecting the house style.
If you go looking for cider; if you arrive forewarned and forearmed, it could be easy to consider this place the world’s cider epicentre. Nowhere else on earth has anything like the txotx season; every bar in San Sebastián sells cider by the bottle. This is a place with distinct, unique celebrations and styles and festivals; the cideries produce almost entirely dry, natural cider and present it in beautiful, fluted 750ml bottles, for all the world like Alsace white or German Riesling. Look around anywhere that sells alcohol and you’ll see a real local cider; a bottle being shared by students, a weathered old Basque nailing two fingers at a time, a couple making their way through a Euskal Sagardoa at a restaurant.
And yet. In every store, cider sits cheaply on the bottom shelf as tourists and locals alike pass it over for wine and beer. Outside Astigarraga much of the cider is hidden from view; you have to know it’s there and ask for it, and they’ll seldom have a selection. Talk to anyone outside the industry and they’ll sniff at cider as a second citizen, a bit of fun, a festival drink. Not something for your Sunday best, not a bottle to produce to impress your guests. The industry itself is still recovering from ruinous years under Franco; a hundred years ago the average Basque drank fifty litres of cider per year – now it’s just about eight. Production is down by twenty million litres, orchard acreage is a third of what it once was. Industry has enveloped Astigarraga and Hernani; in living memory this was all fields and farms, now it’s concrete-carpeted car dealerships, workshops and bus lanes. Barely anything made here leaves the region; when I spoke to friends and relatives about San Sebastián, not one of them brought up the cider. Most were surprised to hear that it existed.
The picture is improving. Numbers might be down on 1913, but they’re worlds ahead of 1967, when as little as a litre per person was drunk every year. Led by Zapiain, Basque cider seems to be looking outward more, to be less insular than it once was. To be something that people talk about, are curious about, make pilgrimages to drink. The PDO was put in place just a few short years back with a focus on provenance, quality and transparency. On smartening up, tucking its shirt in and talking like wine.
And here’s a funny thing. The culture of txotx; of a special festival and a set menu with all of its ingrained rites and bespoke rituals, really isn’t any older than my parents. Reading about it at home I had always assumed that it was some handed-down, centuries-old tradition. In fact it began around the same time as the Beatles. From nothing to a million visitors in just over half a century. All of them eating together, in a cidery, drinking cider. Tradition, for all its nostalgic allure, was just your grandfather’s bright idea. Basque cider needs to channel the energy, the dynamism, the excitement of the txotx into the glasses of the world. Watch this space. I suspect they just might.
When they do, I suspect the two ciders we’re looking at today will be in the vanguard. They’re the premium edition Euskal Sagardoas from Zapiain and Zelaia. Independently adjudged to be the cream of the crop. The top 1%. 750 mls of either will set you back around €3. Let’s be honest, you can’t even get mugged for that. The geophysicist and I managed to get a few proper Basque cider glasses back from San Sebastián, and I’m even confident enough in my Basque pouring now that I’m allowed to do it over the table. So, never mind the independent Basque adjudicators … let’s see what Malt thinks of this pair.
Zelaia Euskal Sagardoa Premium 2018
Colour: Freshly squeezed lemon juice
On the nose: On the Basque scale of citrus to tropical this sits slap bang in the middle. Wonderfully clean and bright and crisp – vivid green apples, sherbet and lime juice. Guava and fresh passion fruit. If smells were sounds this would be the peal of silver bells.
In the mouth: That acidity is delicious. Just the littlest nip, Sauvignon Blanc level, to keep things zippy and refreshingly tingly. Actually the flavours trend in a Sauvignon direction too. Soft lemons, gooseberries, Granny Smiths, cut grass. It’s sorbet-fresh; clears your palate wonderfully. Clean and elegant and refined and teeming with pretty, thrilling life. Oh – and not a whisper of acetic!
Zapiain Euskal Sagardoa Premium 2019
Colour: See Zelaia.
On the nose: A little deeper and rounder than the Zelaia. The citrus is dialled back, the apples have turned from green to red and the tropical tones of pineapple and passion fruit bear more weight. Still that bright, vivacious sherbet keeping things lively though.
In the mouth: There’s a wonderful, round, softness to that acidity. No one drinking this would call it “acidic” or even “sharp”, by any means – there’s just a splendid cleanliness, enough to be brisk and refreshing. More pineapple, tangerine and deeper tropical tones ride alongside Cox apples and higher florals. Superb balance, with more weight than the average Basque. I could drink this forever.
Given the current state of the world I think it’s safe to say we won’t see these on shelves in the UK any time soon. But if you do come across them, wherever you come across them, buy them on sight. If I could regularly get these for three quid a pop they’d be my summer staples without any shadow of a doubt. As often happens, I’m loathe to pick my favourite – at these prices I really don’t have to. But I’ll give you a hint – it starts with a “Z”. Treat them as the makers wanted them to be treated – poured properly, chilled, with food, as a celebration.
Because, to my mind, that’s what Basque cider is. A part of its environment; a thread in the tapestry rather than the tapestry altogether. Drink it on its own and you’ve almost missed the point. This isn’t whisky, isn’t a solitary sipper, isn’t designed to be the whole, sole focus, no matter how good it is. Cider in the Basque ideal is is the meeting of the orchard with pasture and sea; a rooted link to the tilled earth and the cast net. It’s the bringing of a whole, natural place into our hearths and homes. It’s the land poured into your glass.
Sincerest thanks to Maialen and Haritz for taking the time to show us around Zelaia and Zapiain respectively. The Zapiain was a gift, but such things don’t influence our writeups on Malt.
Basque cider is only drinkable when you run out of water. It might even be a better option to risk your life for a few days than to drink one.
Thanks for reading (if you read it?)
Did a Basque cidermaker forget your birthday though? You may wish to open the windows and take some deep breaths …
Yours, with concern,
No I didn’t read It I will, but Basque cider, come on …
…I know the stuff, I love the place, the people and their products and culture but their cider is an awful drink,… that I buy and drink from time to time, when I am there (yes, right to be concerned !) because I celebrate diversity and genuine stuff and hate uniformisation.
Great article btw.
Well, that’s your opinion and you’re entitled to it.
There’s good and bad Basque cider – as there’s good and bad cider from everywhere. Your IP address suggests you’re commenting from France. Now I’ve had some French cider that’s utter, utter filth. But does that make me say all French cider is bad? Of course not – because it isn’t. It’s mostly good to tremendous, and you’ll find me praising and exploring it in depth elsewhere on this site: https://malt-review.com/2020/02/20/cidrexpo-2020/
If you’re saying Basque cider generally is rubbish I’d suggest it’s because you haven’t tried most of the good stuff (eg the Euskal Sagardoa Premiums above, the Byhur and Byhur 24 champagne-methods from Astarbe, Zapiain’s Ice Cider and Pommeau etc) or because you have a bias against still/dry/acidity-led ciders.
But that’s very much not your problem, not Basque Cider’s.
Thanks for taking the time to read the article. If you take advantage of right to reply and write a piece slating Basque cider I’ll be first to read it. But “I don’t like this, I think it’s horrible” doesn’t constitute an argument.
It’s of course only my opinion. And the ones of many people around me (not only French, as I don’t live in France).
Maybe I didn’t try the right ones, maybe I was expecting a different stuff, rounder, easier on the tongue,…. But I am sure I didn’t buy the cheapest ones.
Too aciditic, not enough fruit, no ripeness, weird bubbles, what else could I say ? The memories take me only back to the sink, where it eventualy ended…
I’ll try premiums next time I am down there. I told you, I am buying it every summer.
It’s quite common to hear this kind of opinions in every traditional cider region when it comes to another cider region/style. For a palate that is used to Breton or Norman ciders, Basque cider is something very weird they weren’t expecting. It happens the same when a Basque cider drinker tastes West Country ciders for the first time, not to say when it’s traditional French cider, which sometimes have a heavy brett character.
Basque cider, as many others, is an acquired taste. But I believe it is a taste that is acquired easily. At least this is what I have been able to observe with the many international cider lovers that I have had the pleasure to guide. It’s dry, sharp and very fresh. It’s perfect, from my point of view, for pairing with fatty foods because it cleans the mouth and invites to eat and drink more.
I remember the first time I tried traditional English ciders. They seemed challenging to me. After a while I have learned to appreciate them and nowadays I miss them because it is not easy to find them where I live.
I think i’s convenient for cider lovers to know better the rest of the styles that are made in the world, because there is great diversity and there are great differences that enriches us all, whether we like them more or less. It is normal that we always return to our cider, as we like to return to the dish that mom (or dad) prepared for us when we were children. But in my case, I also enjoy experiencing and learning new things. Santé!
Hi Adam, good to see you out and about in Pais Vasco, it’s a region I know very well. I was married in Bilbao and have family there. Sidra is popular across the North but particularly in parts of the Basque Country and Galicia. Going to a sideria is something to be enjoyed with a party of friends or family and a great scoff up washed down with Txakoli or Sidra. Michelin food is not expected – good. What we want on these occasions is flavoursome fresh food and lots of it. Clearly the quality if the sidra ranges from okay to good but it’s not in the British style and that might confuse some. Fresh, green, flavours and I’ve no complaint about a bit of acidity because that is required to cut through rich food but works well with fish as well. It’s usually drunk with food and not on its own. It can be quite a local thing and not available everywhere in the region.
By the way, if you’re ever in Madrid there’s a great Basque restaurant called Zerain (Highly recommended – Calle Cervantes) which has the mother of barrels stuck in the wall full of sidra. It spouts from a great height for two metres before arriving into the expertly controlled glass. Sounds like you had a great time – Eating and drinking Basque style is one of life’s great experiences. Cheers. WT
It was only my second time in the region – and my first was just a three-day work trip to Rioja, with a brief stop in Bilbao. Needless to say, we adored this trip and are hoping to go back soon. A partner of a very close friend is from Galicia, so a Northern Spanish road trip is on the cards for when the world’s normal again.
Absolutely agree on the food. Simple, but incredibly well-cooked, and it would easily have fed five of us. We were still creaking at the seams the next day. And the cider matches it perfectly.
Thanks very much for the Madrid tip-off. Sounds like something I’ll have to investigate for sure.
As ever – thank so much for reading and taking the time to comment.
Pingback: Four ciders and perries from Eric Bordelet | Cider Review
Pingback: Bereziartua Edición Gourmet and Ross on Wye Spanish Apples 2019 | Cider Review
Pingback: Glass system: what I drink cider from, when and why | Cider Review
Pingback: Cider and perry and smoke: seven reviews | Cider Review
Pingback: Meet your (perry)maker — Elegast | Cider Review