Reviews
Comments 5

Rock Hill Beara 2018 and Charnwood Browns 2019

By a region’s apples shall ye know it.

This isn’t quite true. Whilst apple varieties, certainly those which are commonly made into cider, don’t yet have the same degree of crossed-border international ubiquity as many wine grapes, the same doesn’t hold for county lines within the UK. Take Dabinett for instance. Responsible for some of Herefordshire’s greatest ciders, and the country’s most widely-planted cider apple. Imagine how much would have been lost had it remained only available in Somerset.

I find it wonderful and fascinating that, at present, you can find cider apples from the West Country growing 500 miles north on the Black Isle. That cidermakers in Herefordshire are taking an interest in the likes of Sussex’s Egremont Russet and Suffolk’s Discovery. I think one of the great joys of the next five to ten years or so, as the interest in apple varieties broadens, will be in gradually unpicking the differences in flavour and texture that are wrought by these subtly differing climates.

That being said, it is interesting – to me, anyway – to consider a county’s native varieties and ponder what they possibly suggest about that county’s historical cider character. So, this being Devon week on Cider Review, I thought I’d dig up a couple of ciders showcasing Devon apples for your delectation.

First up is Beara 2018, from Rock Hill, a Devon cidery of which I had not previously heard and which google seems to be scratching its head over as well. Most of my searches led, bizarrely, to the City of London, and combing social media drew a blank too. So, if anyone has any information on these folk, answers, if you please, on a postcard. (Or in the comments section below.)

Beara is a blend of Tremlett’s Bitter, Sweet Alford and Golden Knob, with Tremlett’s being the dominant component. Tremlett’s Bitter is, in malic terms, the beast of Devon. Notoriously intense of tannin and phenolic, it sits in a similar category to Chisel Jersey as an apple often used only for “seasoning”.

According to Scrattings, Beara has enjoyed a secondary in-bottle fermentation for a natural sparkle. A bottle, at the time of writing, is yours for £9.50.

Rock Hill Cider Beara 2018 – review

Colour: Burnished gold

On the nose: I can’t speak to a huge experience of the other two apples in this blend, but the phenolics – the almost smoky meatiness and earthiness – of the Tremlett’s is coming through very well with beeswax and honeysuckle and yellow fruit. Almost a touch of chorizo. Pretty full-on aromatics.

In the mouth: Mousse, but not to a distracting extent. Full bodied, with tannins that grip but aren’t excessive. Lots of freshness and pith to the fruit – orange and soda, waxy dried apricot, lemon zest. The character of the Tremlett’s really pops – the light cured meat, rainfall on earth and touch of cheese rind. Loads of minerality. Virtually dry. This has a lot of almost Ross on Wye-esque touches, you know. And in my book that will seldom be a bad thing.

In a nutshell: Like this. Loads of varietal character, really well-made.

Sticking to our Devon varieties, but demonstrating the earlier point of inter-county migration, our second stop takes us to Leicestershire’s Charnwood. We’ve met Charnwood before in the form of their 2018 Dabinett, which James wrote up here, and I later added my own notes on here. I would also urge you to read the wonderful cidery profile written by Laura Hadland on Pellicle. The cidery, and its cidermaker, Rob Clough, recently celebrated ten years of production – positively venerable by modern cidery standards! Many of the trees in his orchard have been grafted with scion wood from Ross on Wye, so today’s single variety Browns is well-travelled indeed.

Browns sits at the opposite end of the spectrum to Tremlett’s – classed as a sharp apple; all acid, no tannin. It’s worth noting that Charnwood’s full-juice 2019 clocks in at a hefty 7.3%, which is on the chunky side for Browns despite 2019 being generally a lower sugars year across much of the UK. Sunlight hours? Rainfall? Heat? Tree husbandry? Apple selection? Impossible to draw conclusions from just one sample, but a nice demonstration of the potential curiosities of regionality and the impact of producer.

Hard to find Charnwood online at the moment *coughs loudly in the hope that Scrattings, Fram Ferment and Cat in the Glass will take note* but if you’re lucky enough to live in Leicestershire, a 500ml bottle of this weighs in well under a fiver.

Charnwood Browns 2019 – review

Colour: Gold

On the nose: A bright swathe of high tones – green apple skin, lemon juice, pine and a little wood polish. Very crisp and precise fare. A tiny bit of estery, citrusy disinfectant.

In the mouth: Really zingy, fresh acidity – bright and brisk without being searing or aggressive. Intense flavours of green apple and lemon with that fragrant brush of pine – both needles and wood. Very refreshing. Sits entirely in the high octaves. Very clean – there’s a touch almost of chlorine in the midst of it all, but not in an off-putting way. A cider to drink all through summer.

In a nutshell: A fresh, precise, sensitive expression of its variety. Great value too.

Conclusions

Yep. Lots of time for both of these. The Tremlett’s and the Browns shine through in each one respectively, both totally clean, full-juice, expressive. Neither is wildly complex, perhaps, but both are very tasty. A world apart from each other in flavour, but you can buy either with confidence. Charnwood continues to go up and up in my estimation, and Rock Hill is a name I shall continue to look out for on this evidence.

Anything we can glean from the varieties? Well, whilst they may sit in wholly different malic camps, what stood out to me on tasting them is that they both share a real sense of textural definition. These aren’t pillowy, voluptuous creatures like Dabinett or Yarlington; they’re harder-lined, more structured and direct. Historical records ascribe to Devon cider a particular firmness, be it of tannin or acidity. That’s something that would tally with my experiences of these apples and would explain the historical tendencies towards multiple rackings for sweetness and softness of which I’ve read. That said, I’m making huge theoretical leaps and assumptions here – almost certainly confirmation bias – which I’d advise you to take with a pinch of salt. That notwithstanding my interest in Devon varieties is thoroughly piqued, and I look forward to investigating further in the near future.

This entry was posted in: Reviews

by

In addition to Cider Review I co-edit Graftwood Magazine and contribute to other drinks sites and magazines including Full Juice, Distilled and Burum Collective. I share my home with several hundred bottles, one geophysicist and a small fluffy whirlwind called Nutmeg. CiderReviewAdam on Twitter and Instagram.

5 Comments

  1. Chris Russell-Smith says

    Great reviews, Adam. I have picked up a few of Charnwood’s ciders recently and I look forward to trying them. The Cat in the Glass now have some of them in stock, in case anyone reading this fancies trying them too.

    I think that historical leaps and assumptions is pretty much inevitable when discussing apple varieties. I live in Kent, and the question of what characterises traditional Kent cider seems almost impossible to answer. Most of the locally bred varieties were grubbed up and replaced with commercial eating apple trees, and I can honestly say that I’ve never encountered old and quaintly-named Kentish varieties such as Great Expectations, Polly Prosser and Maidstone Favourite. I’d find it very exciting if Kentish producers took cuttings of these varieties from reference orchards and started planting them again, but I’m not sure if that will ever happen.

    Like

    • Cheers Chris.
      Can’t keep up with what Cat in the Glass have in stock these days! This review was only written three weeks ago and there were no Charnwoods available then – amazing what Nicky’s doing.
      Interesting question re the character of individual county’s ciders. I don’t expect there’ll ever be such a thing again – try and stop anyone outside Somerset using Dabinett or Yarlington Mill. I suppose it’ll come down to what people fancy making and, critically, are incentivised to plant. The price of apples being an absolute joke.
      Many thanks for reading and for taking the time to leave a comment again.
      Best wishes
      Adam W.

      Like

  2. Pingback: Stirring giants: a spotlight on Devon cider | Cider Review

  3. Mike says

    I had the Beara a few months ago and I’m sorry to say I poured it down the drain. To me it was just overpowered with mercaptan/disulphide off aroma and flavour. Interestingly I think this is what contributes to some of the funk in the Ross ciders which you mention the Beara shares a similarity with. I wonder if this is the cured meat flavour you’re referring to? I sometimes get a bit of this in some lambic and geuze beers and I think it’s a funkiness some people enjoy but it was definitely overpowering in this cider. There may be some variation between bottles so mine might not have been representative.

    Thanks so much for doing these reviews, I’m enjoying the website. Not wanting to be negative about things with this comment but just interested in how differently we perceive things.

    Like

    • Hi Mike
      Apologies for the delayed reply. Thanks very much for reading and taking the time to post a comment.
      Sorry you didn’t have a great experience with Beara. Oddly enough I didn’t particularly get on with its stablemate, Cornish Raider.
      Given their methods I would strongly suspect that your bottle was a little reductive. Out of interest, did you leave it in the glass for any time before pouring it away?
      Regarding the cured meat comment – if mine had presented as particularly sulphury I would certainly have mentioned it (as I have in instances elsewhere when those aromas and flavours have presented). I don’t think there’s any point or value in disguising faults with euphemism; it’s something we’ll be avoiding as much as we can on this site. My personal take (from my bottle, at least) was that it cleaved fairly closely to flavours and aromas I’d expect in (relatively) young Tremlett’s Bitter. But obviously can’t account for bottle variation – or indeed individual preferences!
      Anyway – apologies – longer response than intended! Sorry you didn’t enjoy your bottle of Beara, but many thanks indeed for your support for Cider Review.
      Best wishes
      Adam W.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s